Islamophobia in general practice: The Hijabi woman, a struck-off GP and a Turkish lingerie shop


Do we hold unconscious biases about our Muslim patients?

A German study involving 90 general practitioners explored their spontaneous associations with Muslim patients. Many described them through perceived shared characteristics, seemingly treating them as a homogeneous population. 

This raises an uncomfortable question for UK general practice: how often do societal stereotypes enter our consulting rooms, shaping how we perceive and treat Muslim patients?

UK evidence suggests these concerns deserve attention. A BJGP Life analysis found that Muslim women reported poorer primary-care experiences than other women, including greater difficulties accessing appointments and less positive experiences with reception services. It also discussed "Bibi syndrome", a derogatory term reportedly used for older South Asian women whose symptoms are dismissed as exaggerated.

One persistent stereotype portrays Muslim women as submissive, lacking independence and unable to make decisions about their own lives or healthcare. But where do these assumptions originate, and what happens when they influence clinical practice?

Conflating religion with culture

Some perceptions may stem from restrictions imposed in particular parts of the world. In Afghanistan, for example, the Taliban's restrictions on women's education, employment and participation in public life have attracted international condemnation. Such highly visible examples can shape wider perceptions of Muslim women.

However, political regimes, patriarchal cultural practices and Islam itself are not interchangeable. 

The actions of a government or the practices of a particular society should not become a lens through which we judge an individual Muslim woman. Yet these distinctions can become blurred, allowing assumptions about one population to influence how we perceive another.

History tells a different story

Islamic history offers a more complex picture of women's roles. Women became prominent Islamic scholars, participated in military campaigns, served as battlefield medics and undertook public administrative responsibilities.

These contributions challenge the portrayal of Muslim women as historically confined to domestic roles. Today, Muslim women continue to lead as presidents, prime ministers, academics, doctors and professionals across numerous fields. 

A struck-off GP: The power of media framing

Media narratives can reinforce stereotypes by presenting complex events through a cultural lens. The case of Dr Keith Wolverson provides an example. In 2022, LBC reported the case under the headline "GP guilty of misconduct for asking Muslim woman to remove her veil could be struck off". In 2026, The Telegraph reported his removal from the medical register under the headline "Doctor who asked Muslim woman to remove veil struck off".

However, the tribunal findings extended beyond the patient's niqab. Dr Wolverson had claimed that he requested its removal because she spoke "poor English". The tribunal found that she spoke fluent English and considered his justification dishonest. His eventual removal from the register followed further misconduct findings, including continuing to practise while suspended, dishonesty and failure to engage with regulatory proceedings.

By focusing predominantly on the face veil, such headlines risk reducing a wider case of professional misconduct to a controversy about a Muslim woman's religious dress. This risks obscuring the professional standards at stake and reinforcing the very cultural narratives that deserve scrutiny.

A Turkish Lingerie Shop: Challenging unspoken assumptions

In October 2026, a lingerie shop in Alaca, Turkey, opened with a prayer ceremony attended by local officials. Photographs attracted online ridicule, with some questioning the apparent contradiction between religious observance and selling lingerie.

But why should these be incompatible?

The reaction exposes another stereotype: that Muslim women, particularly those who wear hijab, are prudish, asexual or detached from intimacy. Yet religious identity does not negate sexuality. Muslim women, like other women, have relationships, sexual lives and reproductive healthcare needs.

A clinician who presumes that a hijabi woman is unlikely to be sexually active may be less inclined to initiate conversations about contraception, cervical screening, sexually transmitted infections or sexual function. Patients who sense that these subjects are unwelcome may equally feel less comfortable raising concerns about fertility, intimacy or menopause.

The consequences may not be overt discrimination. They may be a question never asked, a conversation never started or a healthcare need left unaddressed.

What This means for general practice

Assumptions extend beyond sexuality. Presuming that a Muslim woman is controlled by her husband or male relatives can undermine her autonomy. Conversely, cultural sensitivity must never mean overlooking signs of domestic abuse or coercion.

Challenging these biases requires more than simply avoiding overt prejudice. It means examining our assumptions, asking rather than presuming, offering every patient the same opportunities to discuss their healthcare needs and allowing individuals to define their own experiences.

Islamophobia in healthcare is not always overt. Sometimes it is subtle: an assumption about a patient's beliefs, relationships, independence or sexuality.

The question is not what we assume when a hijabi woman walks into our consulting room. It is whether we give her the space to tell us who she is.


About the writers

Dr Shahin Saif

MBChB, MRCP, DTMH, MHSc. IHM

Dr Shahin Saif is currently a Portsmouth-based GPST3 with a diverse international medical background. 

His career has spanned global health, tropical and expedition medicine, alongside broad experience across various medical and surgical specialties. He was drawn to general practice by its unrivalled variety and the opportunity to work as a versatile generalist while developing a range of special interests.

Outside medicine, he enjoy reading, learning new things and spending time outdoors. Shahin absolutely loathe the cold and have little enthusiasm for endurance activities. He remains convinced that people who enjoy running marathons are slightly psychopathic!