Adolescent depression
Scope of the guidance
This EGP Update item summarizes recent
guidance on the management of depression in young people. It covers
the recognition and diagnosis of depression in adolescents
presenting in primary care and the various treatment options
available to treat adolescent major depression including drug
therapies and cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT). There is
guidance on when to refer to secondary or tertiary services and
what services should be available. Management of psychosis, anxiety
and other mental health issues are not considered.
Source
Dubicka, B, Wilkinson P. Evidence-based treatment of adolescent
major depression. Evid Based Ment Health 2007;
10(4): 100-2 http://ebmh.bmj.com/cgi/content/extract/10/4/100
Hazell P. Depression in children and
adolescents.
http://clinicalevidence.bmj.com/ceweb/index.jsp (subscription
required)
National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence.
Depression in Children and Young People Identification and
management in primary, community and secondary care. National
Clinical Practice Guideline Number 28. London: NICE; 2005.
www.nice.org.uk/nicemedia/pdf/cg028fullguideline.pdf
Key points
- Estimates of prevalence of depression in children and
adolescents range between 2-6%. Most episodes last 7-9 months and
nearly half relapse within two years; and as many as two thirds
relapse within five years.
- The risk of depression occurring in adolescence is increased by
family and social circumstances such as single parent families, low
income, unemployment, depression in a parent and drug and alcohol
abuse in parents. The incidence is higher in young people looked
after in social care.
- Milder degrees of ‘sub-threshold’ depression are also common
and these can be difficult to differentiate from normal transient
mood disturbances in adolescence. Adolescent dysthymia is
characterised by chronic low mood, a tendency to brood, low
self-esteem and general gloominess. Young people with a history of
milder depression or dysthymia may be at increased risk of
developing clinical or major depression.
- Most major depression in adolescence occurs against a
background of long-standing psychosocial and family problems.
School refusal, behavioural problems and self-harm are common
features.
2. Screening and diagnosis
- Self-report inventories used in assessment of depression in
adults (e.g. PHQ-9) are not helpful in children and young people.
The mood and feelings questionnaire (MFQ) has been developed for
use in child and adolescent mental health settings, but has not
been validated for use in general practice populations.
- Moodiness, unpredictability and tearfulness are common in
adolescence and are not symptomatic of depression. Look for
pervasive low mood with social withdrawal, inattention to physical
appearance, reduced academic interest and performance, self-harm.
Aggression and promiscuity sometimes occur.
3. Organisation of services
The NICE guidance envisages four tiers of
care:
| Tier |
Provider |
Role |
Severity |
| 1 |
GPs, schools, social services, youth support |
Identification, referral, support, advice, watchful
waiting |
Mild |
| 2 |
Community child and adolescent mental health services
(CAMHS) |
Counselling, group CBT, guided self-help, brief
psychological input, fluoxetine |
persistent mild, dysthymic, moderate |
| 3 |
Multidisciplinary CAMHS teams |
Emergency care, CBT, family therapy, psychotherapy,
fluoxetine, support to tiers 1&2 |
persistent mild, moderate and some severe |
| 4 |
Secondary or tertiary care |
Inpatient care, intensive or longer psychotherapy or
family therapy, other SSRI, anti-psychotics |
severe, unresponsive, recurrent, psychosis |
GPs will refer on to tiers 2 and 3 (see www.nice.org.uk/nicemedia/pdf/cg028fullguideline.pdf)
if:
- depression with ≥ 2 risks for depression
- depression with multiple risk histories in other family
members
- mild depression not responded to interventions in tier 1 after
2-3 months
- moderate/severe depression
- recurrence of depression in those with previous identified
moderate or severe depression
- unexplained self neglect ≥ 1 month
- actively suicidal ideas or plans
4. Treatment
- Mild depression: where symptoms
are short-lived and there is good family support, watchful waiting
within primary care is suitable. Offer follow-up to provide general
support to the patient and family and check for deterioration.
Self-help materials and simple advice regarding sleep hygiene,
regular exercise and nutrition are also useful. Psychological
treatments such as counselling and CBT can be offered if available.
Persistent mild depression should be referred on as for moderate
and severe depression.
- Moderate and severe depression:
refer to child and adolescent mental health services. Medication
and/or specialist psychological care will be needed. If there are
immediate concerns about self-harm or suicide risk, refer urgently
to tier 3 or 4 services. Otherwise, refer to tier 2 services.
- Psychological treatments
- Advice – on exercise, diet and sleep hygiene should be offered
at tier 1 on initial presentation of mild depression and in those
with low mood not meeting the criteria for depression.
- Self-help – via leaflets, booklets and information. Only offer
in the context of appropriate follow-up or a package of care.
- Counselling/interpersonal therapy may be available within
educational settings or by tier 2 CAMHS. Useful in mild depression.
Some tier 2 services are able to offer 6-10 sessions as a brief
intervention.
- Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) is likely to be beneficial
in mild depression and for young people with moderate depression
who refuse medication (see www.nice.org.uk/nicemedia/pdf/cg028fullguideline.pdf).
Some services are able to offer group CBT which can increase access
to treatment for more young people with mild depression. Brief
courses of CBT can be provided over 6-12 weeks. CBT may be offered
in addition to fluoxetine.
- Other brief interventions are sometimes provided at tier 2 such
as brief family therapy.
- Interpersonal therapy (IPT) delivered by social workers looks
promising for young people with mild to moderate depression; but
there are few trained IPT therapists in the UK.
- Longer-term interventions such as psychotherapy and family
therapy are usually offered within tier 3.
- Medication
- Tricyclic antidepressants are not recommended for young people
under the age of 18 years. There is little evidence of their
effectiveness, side effects are common and toxicity is a serious
concern in overdosage.
- Selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitors (SSRIs): fluoxetine is
the first-line treatment for moderate and severe depression in
adolescence as there is good evidence of its safety and efficacy.
It should only be started by a specialist (rather than a GP). There
is conflicting guidance about whether any SSRIs other than
fluoxetine should be prescribed to adolescents following concerns
about safety eg increased risk of suicide, and effectiveness.
Practical tips
for the busy GP >>
EGP 1. May 2008